France Should Acknowledge Its Responsibility For Africa


Karen Attiah

Published Jul 17, 2017 at 8:00 am (Updated Jul 17, 2017 at 1:03 am)


> > Make text smaller Make text larger
  • Emmanuel Macron

    Emmanuel Macron

Related Stories

Emmanuel Macron triggered a social-media storm last week when a cropped video emerged of him using the word civilisation in a speech about Africa, women and why the continent seems to have so many problems.

At the G20 summit, The French President took a question from an Ivorian journalist on why there is no Marshall Plan for Africas development. Macron responded: The challenge of Africa, it is totally different, it is much deeper, it is civilisational today. What are the problems in Africa? Failed states, the complex democratic transitions, demographic transitions, which is one of the main challenges facing Africa.

He went on to say that women in some places in Africa have seven or eight children, which is destabilising for the continent.

This is the second time in a week that the C-word has sparked backlash in a presidential speech on the international stage. The previous week during his speech in Warsaw, Donald Trump sounded the white-nationalist dog whistle when he invoked Western civilisation as supreme, citing the creation of symphonies and nuclear weapons.

The word civilisation, when used in discussions of economic or political development, often serves as a code, implying that a nations successes and failures can be attributed to immutable, essentialist characteristics of its people. There is a long, shameful history of nations invoking civilisational difference to justify colonialism, war and racial oppression.

To be fair, Macrons full remarks sounded like what one would hear in the halls of a garden-variety Western international development agency. He emphasised that some countries are experiencing remarkable economic growth even as they suffer from trafficking, terrorism and other problems.

Still, Macrons statements are reminiscent of the mission civilisatrice, the civilising mission of French colonialism. As Siddhartha Mitter put it in Quartz: Macrons statements fall into a tradition of condescending statements about Africa that point to every cause of the continents difficulties other than colonialism and its enduring trace.

Macron has been knighted as the centrist in shining armour fighting for liberal values, having vanquished the nakedly xenophobic presidential campaign of far Right leader Marine Le Pen in the national election this year. Macron is clearly no Le Pen or Trump, but his patronising remark, couched in conventional World Bank parlance about demographic transitions and public-private partnerships, reveals a simplistic white mans burden philosophy underlying much of the Wests thinking about Africa.

Technocratic racism guised as development policy can be much harder to challenge than populist bellowing from Trump or Le Pen.

Macron could just have easily used his speech to illuminate the ways in which Frances post-colonial presence continues to weigh on Africas development. He could have started by addressing two other C-words: CFA franc and counterterrorism.

One of the more controversial features of French-African relations is the CFA franc, the common currency of 14 former French colonies in West Africa and Central Africa, which was created in 1945. The CFA franc CFA stands for the French version of financial community of Africa is pegged to the euro at a fixed rate determined by the French treasury. African states and development economists have long complained that the CFA franc has held back economic development in these countries, since the introduction of the euro has created structural current account deficits in CFA franc countries.

Further, under the CFA franc regime, excess foreign exchange reserves from these countries are held in special operations accounts in the French treasury. Some critics characterise the CFA franc arrangement as a form of monetary imperialism. Le Pen called for the end of the CFA franc, saying that she agreed that it hindered African development. Macron has said he would leave it up to Africans to decide whether to leave the currency.

As for counterterrorism, France has increasingly militarised its security policy towards the continent, taking the lead on military interventions in the Sahel and Sahara regions, and in Central Africa. France has a sprawling network of military bases across the continent, another legacy of colonial days.

France drew scorn from the internationally recognised Libyan Government last year for admitting for the first time that it had stationed special forces in the eastern part of the country without co-ordinating with Libyan authorities. French peacekeepers have been embroiled in scandal in the Central African Republic, after allegations that troops sexually abused children while deployed there in 2013. No charges have been brought against the French soldiers.

Rather than criticising Africans alleged failings, and instead of sustaining a culture of colonial dependency, Macron could help African nations build self-sufficiency. He could, for example, press for the opening of French and European markets to African goods and exports. And for all of the money and effort that France has spent on militarising its engagement with the continent, it has woefully underinvested in supporting democracy and good governance, and has a history of supporting dictators.

This may help to explain why so many former French colonies are wracked by civil unrest and governance vacuums.

Cest dommage its a shame that Macron, Frances youngest leader since Napoleon, didnt use his platform to acknowledge Frances problematic role in Africas past, and open the door for new ways of thinking about Africas future.

Karen Attiah is The Washington Posts Global Opinions Editor

> > Make text smaller Make text larger

You must be registered or signed-in to post comment or to vote.

Published Jul 17, 2017 at 8:00 am (Updated Jul 17, 2017 at 1:03 am)

France should acknowledge its responsibility for Africa

What you

Need to


1. For a smooth experience with our commenting system we recommend that you use Internet Explorer 10 or higher, Firefox or Chrome Browsers. Additionally please clear both your browser's cache and cookies - How do I clear my cache and cookies?

2. Please respect the use of this community forum and its users.

3. Any poster that insults, threatens or verbally abuses another member, uses defamatory language, or deliberately disrupts discussions will be banned.

4. Users who violate the Terms of Service or any commenting rules will be banned.

5. Please stay on topic. "Trolling" to incite emotional responses and disrupt conversations will be deleted.

6. To understand further what is and isn't allowed and the actions we may take, please read our Terms of Service

7. To report breaches of the Terms of Service use the flag icon

Radiuniverse Samsung S9 For Free

Want To Win - iPhone X (SOI) Click Here

Source : http://www.royalgazette.com/opinion/article/20170717/france-should-acknowledge-its-responsibility-for-africa

France should acknowledge its responsibility for Africa
Macron blames 'civilization' for Africa's problems. France should acknowledge its own responsibility (Washingtonpost)
'Daily Show' host Trevor Noah accused of racism after insisting that France's World Cup champs are really from Africa
Africa: Whose World Cup Victory Is It Anyway, Africa or France?
Trevor Noah accused of racism after saying France’s World Cup champs are from Africa
Trevor Noah’s feud with France over race, identity, and Africa, explained
In the fight for immigrants, Mahony works out of the spotlight and his successor steps up
Polisario Unveils Algeria’s Support for Separatism in Morocco