Supreme Court Declines To Address Ruling On College Athletes


The Supreme Court will not hear the appeals from either side on the O'Bannon v. NCAA class action case regarding compensation for college athletes. This leaves in place a lower court ruling deeming that the college athletics association violated antitrust laws, but also the appeal to that ruling that prevents college athletes from being paid. Thus, college sports remains unchanged for the time being, and therefore so does the limbo status of video games based on college football in particular.


In 2014, U.S District judge Claudia Wilken ruled that the NCAA's laws forbidding college athletes from being compensated for use of their likeness violated antitrust laws. Last year the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned Wilken's ruling regarding payments, but not the antitrust segment. Thus, both the O'Bannon side and the NCAA had reason to seek a Supreme Court ruling. 

Previously, EA, makers of the NCAA franchise, and the Collegiate Licensing Company split from the O'Bannon lawsuit in a $60 million settlement with the plaintiffs.

[Source: ESPN]


Our Take

Unfortunately for video game fans waiting for the return of the NCAA franchise, these kinds of legal wins and losses are exactly what must be settled before we see a return of the NCAA franchise or anything else. Even if everything were settled one way or another, there still could be significant complications – such as having to hash out deals with scores of licensors  – that could make an NCAA title prohibitively expensive.

Radiuniverse Samsung S9 For Free

Want To Win - iPhone X (SOI) Click Here

Source : http://www.gameinformer.com/b/news/archive/2016/10/03/supreme-court-declines-to-hear-ncaa-appeal.aspx

Supreme Court Declines To Hear NCAA Case Appeals
Brett Kavanaugh, Supreme Court Front-Runner, Once Argued Broad Grounds for Impeachment
Big questions arise for NCAA following ruling on sports gambling
The Daily 202: Inside the House GOP super PAC’s strategy to localize every key race
A Pregnancy-Disability-FMLA Triple Whammy
In Upholding Trump’s Travel Ban, Supreme Court Ratifies Worldview That Worries Colleges
States, NCAA should embrace Supreme Court gambling decision
Supreme Court to hear New Jersey sports betting case
Constitution’s wide latitude for a president causing major legal headaches
Dave Solomon's State House Dome: A big shift on election law