The Uncounted

The Times story is one of faulty intelligence driving wrong-headed assumptions that decimate innocent lives and embitter survivors. It is a story about how a legal and bureaucratic fog can make it almost impossible for tragic mistakes to come to light, too often leaving instead a false sense of comfort that such mistakes never happened at all. And it is a story about a policy that warrants honest discussion, and change. We both worked with that policy up close. In the Obama White House, one of us was responsible for human rights, the other for coordinating the counter-ISIS campaign. In this respect, we were part of an administration that fell short.

At the outset, two points. First, painful lessons of the article aside, the U.S. military is staffed up and down its ranks with officers who care about and seek to protect innocent life. Likewise, President Obama and his senior National Security Council team were convinced of the moral and strategic importance of preserving civilian life in conflict, understood transparency as important to democratic accountability, and were committed to operating within the rule of law.

Second, the Times article carries the unmistakable implication that things will get worse. The Trump administration has celebrated a no-holds-barred approach to the fight against ISIS, given greater deference to ground commanders, loosened restrictions imposed by its predecessor, and expanded the fight to an ever-growing number of Middle Eastern and African theaters. This adds up to a quasi-automatic recipe for greater civilian casualties. Independent monitoring organizations have tracked the numbers, and invariably they point to a serious uptick in civilian deaths in Iraq and Syria since January 2017. The explanation lies partly in the transition in Iraq and Syria toward the final, more urban phase of the conflict in the heavily populated cities of Mosul and Raqqa. But partly only. It also lies in policy guidance, as well as in matters such as tone, attitude, and priorities set at the very top—including by the commander in chief. These have a way of trickling down and affecting performance on the battlefield.


Trending Hairstyles

Source : https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2017/12/isis-obama-civilian-casualties/548501/

An Accounting for the Uncounted
Moore Doubles Down On Refusal To Concede Race, Suggests Voter Fraud
Pierce County says changes made after 152 ballots went uncounted in August primary
Podcast Pick: Overwhelmed by numbers in the news? Planet Money's 'The Indicator' can help
Roy Moore Still Won’t Concede Defeat: ‘The Battle Rages On’
The International Stillbirth Scandal: Every Day 7,100 Stillborn Babies Die
Defiant Roy Moore still won’t concede
Border Deaths: Uncounted numbers
Elections chief says automatic recount unlikely in Alabama race; Huckabee, Jones urge Moore to concede
The Wake Up: Doug Jones Would Likely Win If A Recount; Gwen Moore Faces Racists And ‘SNL’ Has Head Black Writer